Juan Soto’s time with the New York Yankees lasted just one season, but it was enough to leave a lasting impression on both the organization and its fan base. Although Soto has spent more time with the Washington Nationals, San Diego Padres, and now the New York Mets in his MLB career, his lone year in the Bronx produced some of the most memorable moments of his career. Now, more than a year removed from wearing pinstripes, Soto reflected on that unforgettable season.
MORE: MLB Power Rankings: All 30 teams ranked ahead of the 2026 All-Star Game
A Moment Yankees Fans Will Never Forget
When asked about his time with the Yankees, Soto didn’t hesitate to point to one memory above all others. According to a recent interview, Soto said, “Celebrating in Cleveland was one of the greatest memories I can ever have.”
The comment was a clear reference to his iconic extra-inning home run against the Cleveland Guardians in the American League Championship Series. That blast not only won the game but also clinched the series and sent the Yankees to their first World Series since 2009.
It’s a moment that remains etched in Yankees history and one that Soto himself clearly hasn’t forgotten.
A Short Stay That Left a Lasting Legacy
Despite spending only one season in New York, Soto quickly became a fan favorite. He formed one of baseball’s most dangerous lineups alongside Aaron Judge and helped guide the Yankees through a memorable postseason run.
Although the Yankees ultimately fell to the Los Angeles Dodgers in the World Series, the expectation around baseball was that Soto would remain in the Bronx for years to come. Instead, he shocked many by signing a massive long-term contract with the crosstown New York Mets in free agency.
No Regrets About 2024
Even though Soto now calls Queens home, it’s clear he still looks back fondly on his season with the Yankees. His comments about the celebration in Cleveland suggest that, regardless of how his free agency unfolded, the memories he made during that postseason remain among the highlights of his career.
Yankees fans may always wonder what could have been had Soto stayed in pinstripes, but they’ll also remember that for one magical season, he helped bring the franchise back to the Fall Classic. And judging by his latest remarks, Soto will remember it just as fondly.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —
