Sports

Inside the rise and evolution of Ohio State's club football team

It was a 90-degree September evening in Columbus, and the setting sun was relentlessly beating down on the Lincoln Tower Park recreational fields next to Ohio Stadium. A group of students began to dress in football pads and scarlet, white and gray colored helmets. The Ohio State marching band was wrapping up practice with a run-through of “Buckeye Battle Cry.”

The players, fresh off back-to-back national championships, were about to practice next to “The Shoe.” Unlike the Buckeyes who play in Ohio Stadium on Saturdays, though, nobody there was getting paid. The athletes weren’t getting NIL money. They weren’t on athletic scholarships. The coaches were volunteers.

What drives the Ohio State club football team is simply a love of football.

Tommy Delaney walks on the field during the Ohio State Club Football practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

“I think it’s what this program should have always been,” coach James Grega Jr. said before practice. “I hope we haven’t peaked.”

Former and current players will tell you that Grega, who spends around 30 hours a week outside of his day job working with the club team, is a major reason for that success. By day, Grega is a content specialist at OSU’s College of Arts and Sciences. In his free time, he has poured his energy into Ohio State club football, which has dominated its 15-team league, the National Club Football Association, with four championships in the past six seasons.

During the Division I varsity team’s bye week, the club team went viral for beating Wright State 105-0. It set NCFA records for most points and widest margin of victory. The previous points record was 91, set by the Buckeyes two years earlier. On Nov. 15, the club team won 65-8 over Oakland to get to an 8-0 record and advance to an eighth straight conference championship.

Along with their success and massive blowout victories, six players since 2020 have gone from the Ohio State club team to the Division I team as walk ons.

How Kellyn Gerenstein, Chris Booker began OSU club football’s legacy

“Club football saved my life.”

Born and raised in Chicago, Illinois, Kellyn Gerenstein played quarterback from age 6 through high school. He considered a couple of Division II offers before deciding to pursue academics over athletics, enrolling in Ohio State’s engineering program.

When he arrived at OSU in 2018, one of the constants in his life − playing organized football − vanished. He went through the motions at school but felt like he lacked structure. The pressure mounted. At one point, Gerenstein considered leaving Ohio State.

The Ohio State Club Football members lift their helmets during practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

To kill time, Gerenstein would take a duffel bag filled with his high school football cleats and a couple of footballs from home and walk to Lincoln Tower Park late at night. He practiced throwing footballs into the available soccer nets.

“It was the only way for me to stay sane,” Gerenstein said.

The kicker for the club football team was playing pickup soccer and saw Gerenstein whipping footballs around. He told Gerenstein the team needed a quarterback. Admittedly skeptical, Gerenstein showed up to the first practice and met Grega, who was embarking on his first year as coach.

The two immediately clicked.

Head coach James Grega speaks to his players during the Ohio State Club Football practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

Grega played on the club football team in 2012 and became the starter in 2013. Instead of playing the next year, he became the assistant sports editor of The Lantern and pursued journalism. After graduating, Grega missed being on the sideline. He had done some coaching at Westerville South High School while bouncing around writing for various sports publications.

OSU’s club players reached out for Grega, hoping he would come coach them. Not only did he agree to this, but he developed a plan to reform the team’s structure.

“It was very bare bones,” Grega said. “So we’ve kind of built it. When we took over in 2018, unfortunately, the program was on the verge of not collapsing, but folding.”

Grega spent time with the club sports office to ensure the team had field reservations in-season and at Ohio State’s indoor recreation center. With a background in marketing and communications, Grega created a website for recruiting purposes and attempted to bolster the team’s social media presence.

Along with structure, Grega wanted to instill a culture of accountability.

“It’s kind of like any other team,” Gerenstein said. “Like, guys have talent, but if one guy shows up more and works harder than you, we’ll win with that guy. And for the most part, we didn’t really run into that. All the culture and the demand changed.”

That appealed to receiver Chris Booker, who had transferred from Dayton after spending time on the non-scholarship FCS program.

Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver Chris Booker (86) catches a pass during football training camp at the Woody Hayes Athletic Center in Columbus on Tuesday, Aug. 10, 2021.

Booker redshirted his first year with the Flyers and was on the scout team, but he felt drained. Football felt like a job rather than the sport he grew up with.

At Ohio State, Booker focused on his degree. He played flag football as a hobby with his cousin, a fellow student.

“Hey, uh, you can still play,” Booker’s cousin said with assurance.

Though unconvinced, Booker met Grega and came away loving his vision for the program.

“It felt like high school ball, just playing with your friends, enjoying practice, enjoying the game, enjoying every part of football that I grew up loving,” Booker said. “That was something I lacked that I got back with the club team.”

During the season, Booker’s younger brother passed away. The two had won a Missouri high school state championship together and shared a deep connection through football.

“It was very emotional when I was able to get back on the field again,” Booker said. “It was kind of second nature for me to get back out on the field and to be able to have him in spirit with me out there.”

Booker found some healing by throwing himself back into the sport.

“He was really good for us in 2018,” Grega said. “I mean, heads and tails above everyone else.”

In Grega’s first season, the club team won its first four games before losing to the Apprentice School in the Mid-Atlantic Conference title game. Booker played in four games and caught 14 passes for 371 yards and seven touchdowns. He still holds the club record for yards per reception at 26.5.

After the season, Grega approached Booker with an idea. He edited a package of Booker’s club football highlights and wanted to send the tape to a staff member on the Division I team.

“As much as I would love to have you here for three more years, you’re too damn good,” Grega said to Booker.

With Booker’s blessing, Grega sent the tape to Justin Perez, the Buckeyes’ walk-on coordinator at the time. Before long, Booker had earned a spot on the team, the first of Grega’s protegees to do so.

As a walk-on, Booker played in 19 games over two seasons, mostly on special teams. He caught two passes for 27 yards in 2021. He played in both the College Football Playoff semifinal and championship games in the 2020-21 season. He also earned recognition from the team via a Special Teams Player of the Week nod in a 52-17 season-opening win against Nebraska in 2020.

Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver Chris Booker (86) sings "Carmen Ohio" with teammates following a 26-17 win over the Nebraska Cornhuskers in Saturday's NCAA Division I football game at Memorial Stadium in Lincoln, Neb., on November 6, 2021.

“They are an elite, elite program,” Booker said. “And to be able to be a part of that was surreal. … I’m very appreciative of all the people I met there, and everybody that I developed a relationship with and everybody that made my experience better … getting the opportunity to play in the games meant more than I could ever put in words, or express gratitude for.”

Booker now works in finance and coaches at his former high school. Five years removed, he distinctly remembers the final moments of the 2021 Rose Bowl, his last game. As the confetti fell, Booker had a bittersweet feeling. He felt like the credits were rolling on a chapter of his life, but he was grateful club football had made that chapter possible.

Since Booker, five other Ohio State club football players have been elevated to the varsity program. The most recent was Jackson Gula, a safety who joined the team ahead of the 2026 season and joined former club football defensive back Glorien Gough, linebacker Zach Hayes and offensive lineman Ian Gecse on the roster.

Meanwhile, the club football team thrived. With Gerenstein under center and a vocal leader of the club, the team went undefeated in 2019 and floored most of its opponents, winning an NCFA national championship against Oakland.

Gerenstein won the NCFA’s offensive MVP in 2019. Though the team did not play in 2020 due to COVID, it picked up where it left off in 2021 and won another national championship.

Gerenstein was thriving off the field as well. He changed his major from engineering to sport industry. Instead of going to the library to read his class textbooks, he would go and watch Dwayne Haskins highlights. He knew football was his path to a professional future.

In 2022, the Buckeyes lost the club national championship game to Gordon State, which was Gerenstein’s last game. He finished his club football career with a 24-4 record and set several team records. His No. 4 was the first retired by the club team.

The same year, Gerenstein started a year-long recruiting internship with the Ohio State varsity team. He learned how to study film and be a part of scouting operations through Billy Homer, OSU’s college scouting coordinator.

Before graduating, Gerenstein was invited by a staff member to participate in Ohio State’s pro day and worked out with Ohio State players in front of NFL scouts, the only non-varsity player to do so. The players participating included future NFL players C.J. Stroud, Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Paris Johnson.

While there, he made a connection with the San Francisco 49ers and earned a scouting internship that began after graduation.

Gerenstein was hired at Boston College as an assistant director of recruiting. After a year there, Gerenstein was connected with Buffalo Bills assistant general manager Brian Gaine and became a scouting assistant in 2024. This past July, he was promoted to a combine scout recruiting players for the Bills in Georgia and the Carolinas.

“I think that club [made me] realize how much joy and passion I had for the game that I knew I loved in high school,” Gerenstein. said, “but it wasn’t until college that I realized I couldn’t live without it.”

How Ohio State club football expanded

Since taking over in 2018, Grega has created structure in the program. The club team has a robust website used for recruiting players. The team has a 10-person coaching staff with position-specific specialists. There is enough donated equipment, including pads, helmets and jerseys, for a 44-player roster. They’ll even play against junior varsity squads from Division III teams; this year, the club played Wilmington College on Oct. 11, and the Buckeyes won 47-13.

Stosh Niezgoda puts on his pads before the Ohio State Club Football practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

Grega made a good first impression by recognizing Booker’s talent and has kept a steady relationship with Tim Hinton, the executive director for football relations and special assistant to coach Ryan Day. Once or twice a year, Grega will check in with staff members such as Hinton and will provide information and tape of a player he deems a potential walk-on candidate.

Resources for the club team have vastly changed since Grega’s first year. In the spring and the summer, the Division I team offers Grega equipment that would not be sellable at the pro shop. The Division I program has gifted around 70 sets of shoulder pads, along with chin straps, mouthpieces and more leftover equipment. This year, the team got a new set of jerseys, along with alternate game pants.

Grega asks players to provide their own helmets, which could cost around $500 or more for a new model. Each player also pays a $375 fee that goes toward travel fees. The club Buckeyes’ first game of the season was at Michigan State, with the team taking passenger vans (driven by coaches) and staying overnight. For the in-state games, the team carpools.

Like Booker and Gerenstein, players join the club team because of their passion for competitive football. Defensive lineman Matt Humphreys, for example, was a valedictorian at his high school in Jackson, Ohio, and played FCS Division I football at Robert Morris on academic scholarship.

A pair of abdominal tears and COVID restrictions kept Humphreys off the field for all but two games of the spring in 2021 in a COVID-adjusted season. He decided it was time to transfer, but did not like any of the options and went to OSU as a regular student.

Mathew Humphreys battles Elijah Lowden in a one-on-one drill during the Ohio State Club Football practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

Humphreys found out about the club by scanning the school website and reached out via social media. Grega responded with a call, inviting Humphreys to a practice.

Humphreys has spent three years on the team and is a staple of the defensive line. In his final year of eligibility, he is chasing the club defensive stats records. Through four seasons, Humphreys has 56 solo tackles and 21.5 sacks. He hopes he can coach football in the future and plans to pursue a career in finance.

“With the club level, these are guys that are paying to do it, and there’s no requirement to do it,” Humpherys said. “The only thing they’re getting out of it is enjoyment of the game.”

Corbyn Aleshire spent last year on the club team as the backup quarterback. He spent four years on his high school team as a backup in Homestead, Florida. After exploring Division III options, Aleshire decided he wanted to go to Ohio State and pursue construction management. He is also a lifelong Buckeyes fan with grandparents from Lima and Dayton.

Corbyn Aleshire makes a pass during the Ohio State Club Football practice at Lincoln Tower Park on Sept. 1, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio.

Upon arriving at Ohio State in 2025, Aleshire discovered the club football team online and filled out the recruiting form. Grega reached out to Aleshire. A year later Aleshire was in line for the starting job, and in his first home start, he had four touchdowns in a 52-6 win against George Mason.

“I thought [Grega] was a super cool dude,” Aleshire said. ” … I love his offense and he’s a really good salesman, that’s for sure.”

There have been opportunities for Grega’s coaches, as well. Brendan McNeill, formerly the team’s defensive line coach, was elevated to defensive coordinator. McNeill played at St. Charles Prep. He played and coached with semi-professional teams in Columbus, as well as coaching youth-level teams before meeting Grega and joining his staff.

When McNeill has time away from his information technology job and family responsibilities, he spends free time watching plays and communicating with prospective students as the club recruiting coordinator.

This year McNeill earned a two-year coaching fellowship with the United Football League through the National Coalition of Minority Football Coaches, spending last summer working with former Buckeyes Ted Ginn Jr., Larry Grant and Curtis Terry on the Columbus Aviators staff.

“I was nervous, but they pulled me right in, and that was a beautiful experience,” said McNeill. “I can’t wait to do it again.”

Eight years in, Grega has amplified the club football team to suit the personal goals of his players and staff. He hopes he can coach a program full-time some day.

“I think a lot of people see the word ‘club’ on a resume and they kind of dismiss us,” Grega said. “But again, that’s why we work so hard to continue to build this thing, because we want to be taken seriously.”

Day acknowledged the club’s legitimacy at an Oct. 27 press conference.

“We’ve been able to get a couple of guys on the team, which has been great,” Day said. “I can’t sit here and say it’s been a lifeblood of the program, but it is an opportunity for some guys in the program and be part of what we do here. You just never know, and maybe there’s a way to build it stronger in the future.”

Dan Aulbach is the Breaking & Trending Sports Reporter at the Columbus Dispatch.He can be reached at daulbach@dispatch.com or @aulbachdan on X.

This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: Inside the rise and evolution of Ohio State’s club football team

Read More

Related Articles

Back to top button