The cacophony had already started as Game 3 was ending Wednesday night – there were some audible chants of “Fire Boone” at Yankee Stadium as the Rays were plunging a dagger into what is another empty Yankee year.
Tampa Bay swept the Yanks out of the best-of-five AL Division Series and the Rays now head to the AL Championship Series. The Yankees wade into the uncertainty of a baseball winter while unpacking raw emotions, so disappointed by the loss that Aaron Boone talked of a “broken clubhouse” in his postgame press conference.
“It’s the worst,” Boone said. He repeated: “It’s the worst.”
It’s also the beginning of, right or wrong, the Boone watch. We live in an era of Blame Culture, after all, right? The manager has one more year remaining on his contract and while there are plenty of fans who make their feelings well known about his job performance – see the above chant or just search him on social media – it seems unlikely, at least in the immediate aftermath of the end of their season, that Boone won’t be the Yankee manager whenever the 2027 season begins.
That’s in part because of the looming labor negotiations that could very well result in a lockout and delay the season. If labor leaves teams idle while the lawyers negotiate, that means the offseason could be shortened. Managers can’t manage during the lockout, and a new guy couldn’t get to know his new players and how he should handle so many varied personalities. Can the expensive Yankees, presumably built to contend, really cram a new manager into a truncated winter as they try to get over their 17-year championship drought?
Plus, Boone probably did one of his finest jobs managing the Yankees this season. The end result wasn’t to the “standard” of a World Series title that the Yanks set every season – one they haven’t fulfilled since 2009, by the by. But they won 93 games while missing big names such as Aaron Judge, Max Fried, Gerrit Cole, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger for significant stretches. Then they won their Wild Card Series without Judge, too.
Whether fans like it or not, some of his players were happy to back Boone after the loss, too.
“He’s our manager,” Judge said. “He runs this ship. He puts us in the right position to go out there and succeed, especially in a season like this where I’m banged up, missing 100 games.
“For him to manage it the way he did and put us in the best position to get into the postseason and get an opportunity to win the World Series, he’s definitely had our backs.”
“He’s amazing,” added Cam Schlittler, who flourished into a likely AL Cy Young winner with Boone as his manager. “He’s someone who’s going to put his players first and I think that’s really important…There’s not a single day where I haven’t trusted him or a decision he’s made. I have a great relationship with him. I’ll back him up. I hope I’m playing here for a long time and he’s still the manager.
“He might take the blame for the way we perform, but, at the end of the day, it comes down to us and the expectation needs to be a little bit better.”
Of course, in a group so large, not everyone is going to be happy with the manager all the time. Jazz Chisholm Jr., who did not start Game 3 after a poor Game 2, seemed miffed about the benching – as is his right, certainly – afterward.
When asked about sitting, he replied, “No comment. Next.”
Chisholm, who later entered the game as a pinch-hitter and then went to second, also said he would have appreciated a conversation with Boone about not starting the game. So, yes, it seems impossible for a manager to satisfy every one of his charges.
Boone himself sounded like someone who expects to be back. “Yeah, of course,” Boone said when asked. Then he tried to steer the conversation back to the bitter moment of losing, not his job security. “That’s for another day,” he added. “Right now is about trying to reflect on this, trying to connect with guys right now as much as I can. Appreciative of a lot of things, but those conversations and things are for another day.”
No one is saying there aren’t legitimate gripes about the manager, either. When a team has a defensive collapse like Game 2, coming just two years after a similar defensive debacle in Game 5 of the 2024 World Series, it’s fair to wonder if there’s a culture issue. No, the manager wasn’t the one bungling ground balls or sailing throws, but managers ultimately should answer for performance, too.
There are plenty of Yankee fans that believe not winning the World Series is a fireable offense and they forget all about the sustained success the Yanks have enjoyed. Boone, for instance, is one of three Yankee managers to reach the postseason in eight of their first nine seasons or better with the Yanks. Joe Torre and Casey Stengel, pretty good company, are the others.
Only Boone and Dave Roberts have taken their first-ever managing job and made the playoffs eight times in their first nine years, too.
No, he hasn’t won it all, like Roberts. Or Torre. Or Stengel. He’s got to be better and so do the Yankees. Too many of these season-enders have felt the same.
But you might have to get used to the idea that he’ll be back. The injuries, the labor strife, all make that the easiest answer for the Yankees.
